Lately, I’ve been using watercolor pencils more frequently, and I prefer them to normal colored pencils for many things. I decided to share my experience so you can get the best ones. Let’s have a look!
Top 4 Watercolor Pencils Compared
40 colors in hard case :: Includes a selection of colors from the Museum Aquarelle pencil line :: Water-soluble, soft, smooth, strong lead :: High pigment concentration :: Dry or wet drawing on paper or cardstock :: For watercolor drawing, shading, accurate lines, washes and blurring
60 colors in metal tin :: Includes a selection of colors from the Albrecht Durer pencil line :: Water-soluble, break-resistant lead :: Acid-free pigments in vibrant colors :: Dry or wet drawing :: For watercolor drawing, shading, accurate lines, washes and blurring
48 colors in metal tin :: Includes a selection of colors from the Mondeluz Aquarelle watercolor pencils line :: Water-soluable vibrant pigments :: Perfect for wet and dry surfaces, such as vellum, canvas, and watercolor paper :: Brush over with water to soften the lines, and create watercolor paint effect, or dip into water before drawing to create rich strokes
120 colors in metal tin :: Vibrant and intense pigments :: Break-resistant leads :: For wet and dry techniques :: Great for blending and layering
Overview: Best Watercolor Pencils For Artists in 2026
Join Evolve Artist Program, the world’s simplest art training method with results guaranteed!
My Pick: Caran D’Ache Museum Aquarelle Watercolor Pencils
The Caran D’Ache Museum Aquarelle pencils are hands-down the finest watercolor pencils available today.
They are artist-grade, deeply pigmented, perfectly blendable, and exceptionally water-soluble. Their smooth, consistent laydown, wet or dry, rivals even the best watercolor paints, offering unmatched brightness, saturation, and durability without fading.
While expensive, they’re a true investment and a joy to use, inspiring creativity rather than limiting it.
Also Great: Faber Castell Albrecht Durer Watercolor Art Pencils
If you want THE best watercolor pencils but can’t justify the splurge on Caran d’Ache, the Faber-Castell Albrecht Dürer pencils are the next best thing. They are an easy recommendation for serious artists.
With rich, vibrant color even when dry, and superb control when wet, these pencils are versatile enough for both fine detail and expressive washes.
They’re also highly fade-resistant, beautifully made, and feel fantastic in use, luxurious, precise, and inspiring. In all aspects except perhaps absolute brilliance, they rival the best, making them the finest watercolor pencils for fine artists at a slightly more accessible price point.
Alternative Pick: Derwent Watercolour Pencils
Many artists actually prefer Derwent Watercolour pencils over the Albrecht Dürer set, especially for their bold, vibrant colors.
While the Faber Castell excel in control and subtlety, Derwents bring unmatched saturation and impact; perfect for color-intensive work like illustration or commercial art.
They’re still highly precise, durable, and professional-grade, making them a favorite among working artists. Ideally, you’d want both: Derwent for expressive color and Dürer for fine detail.
But if boldness and creative freedom are your priority, Derwent Watercolour pencils are the best watercolor pencils for commercial artists.
Budget Pick: Koh-I-Noor Mondeluz Aquarelle Watercolor Pencils
If the above sets feel a bit pricey, the Koh-I-Noor Mondeluz Aquarelle pencils offer an outstanding mid-range alternative with rich, vibrant colors, smooth laydown, and impressive control, wet or dry.
They balance expressive freedom and precision beautifully, with quality and durability that rival more expensive brands.
Whether you’re layering, blending, or dialing back to subtle tones, these pencils deliver, and they feel great to work with. For artists seeking top performance without breaking the bank, the Mondeluz is my pick for the best value watercolor pencils on the market.
Student Pick: Lyra Graduate Aquarelle Watercolor Pencils
The Lyra Graduate Aquarelle pencils are an excellent choice for beginners or art students exploring watercolor, offering surprisingly high performance at a very affordable price.
With smooth laydown, vibrant, fade-resistant pigments, and great water responsiveness, they make it easy to learn and experiment without frustration.
These pencils provide consistent, beautiful results that support both basic and advanced techniques, helping build skills and confidence. For anyone starting out, they’re my top pick for the best watercolor pencils for students and beginners.
Budget Pick: Castle Art Supplies Watercolor Pencils Set
120 colors in metal tin :: Vibrant and intense pigments :: Break-resistant leads :: For wet and dry techniques :: Great for blending and layering
If you’re looking for a big, affordable set to explore watercolor pencils without worry, the Castle Art Supplies 120-color set is hands-down the best cheap option I’ve found.
Unlike most budget sets that feel chalky, weak, or unresponsive, these pencils offer bold, smooth color, wet or dry, with great blendability and a surprisingly premium feel.
Stored in a convenient three-layer metal box, they’re comfortable to use, durable, and genuinely fun to work with. For beginners or hobbyists wanting lots of colors on a budget, this set is a clear winner.
How to Choose the Best Watercolor Pencils
Below are the core criteria to select your new watercolor pencils, each with a quick explanation and bite-size checklists you can use in-store or at home.
Pigment Quality & Lightfastness
High-quality pigment gives richer color, smoother washes, and better longevity in finished art. Lightfast pencils resist fading on display.
- Look for: artist-grade pigments, clear lightfast ratings (e.g., ASTM I/II, Blue Wool 7–8, or robust in-brand scales), saturated swatches.
- Watch out for: dull, chalky laydown; colors that shift a lot when wet.
- Quick test: make a dry swatch, then activate half with water—both halves should stay vivid and close in hue.
Solubility & Wash Behavior
Great watercolor pencils dissolve cleanly, without gritty residue or stubborn lines (unless you want them).
- Look for: fast, even activation; ability to pull a full value range (dark to pale) from one stroke.
- Watch out for: “ghost lines” that won’t dissolve, patchy areas, heavy waxy films.
- Quick test: draw a gradient bar, then use a damp brush to pull color down—aim for a smooth fade.
Core Hardness & Dry Performance
The core affects detail control, coverage, and how the pencil feels on paper.
- Look for: a balance that fits your style—softer cores for lush coverage, firmer cores for crisp lines and hatching.
- Watch out for: crumbly points, frequent breakage, or glazing over the paper too quickly.
- Quick test: write fine lettering, shade a block, then layer—note control and comfort.
Layering, Blending & Glazing
Watercolor pencils should stack color without tearing paper or turning muddy.
- Look for: clean mixes, workable glazing (light transparent layers), smooth layering both dry and wet.
- Watch out for: muddy blends, paper pilling, or layers that lift uncontrollably when re-wet.
- Quick test: lay yellow, glaze blue on top (wet), and check for a clean green without scumble.
Color Range & Palette Design
More colors aren’t always better; a thoughtful palette beats a giant tin you barely use.
- Look for: strong primaries, a natural skin-tone path, useful earths, and a few deep neutrals.
- Watch out for: sets heavy on near-duplicates or novelty hues with weak pigment.
- Tip: if the brand sells open stock, you can start small and expand with your most-used colors.
Paper Compatibility
Paper changes everything—solubility, texture, and how many layers you can build.
- Hot press: smooth for detail and pen-and-wash.
- Cold press: toothy for expressive marks and bigger washes.
- Watch out for: thin paper buckling; overly rough tooth eating points.
- Quick test: try your pencils on the paper you actually plan to use.
Build Quality & Ergonomics
A well-made pencil is accurate, durable, and comfortable over long sessions.
- Look for: centered cores, durable wood (easy sharpening), secure end caps, legible labeling (names, numbers, LF rating).
- Watch out for: off-center cores, splintery wood, loose caps, inconsistent color names.
- Ergonomics: diameter and barrel shape (round vs hex) affect grip fatigue.
Sharpening & Point Retention
Frequent breaks waste time and money.
- Look for: clean shavings, points that hold under pressure, compatibility with your sharpener (handheld or crank).
- Watch out for: core crumble, repeated snap-offs, waxy clogging.
- Tip: use a long-point sharpener or craft knife for finer, stronger points.
Rewetting, Lifting & Permanence
How a color reactivates or lifts after drying affects techniques like glazing and corrections.
- Look for: predictable reactivation (some lift slightly, some set more permanently).
- Watch out for: uncontrollable lifting that ruins previous layers.
- Quick test: let a wash dry fully, then re-wet a corner—note how much it moves.
Price/Value & Grade
Match quality to your goals and budget.
- Artist grade: higher pigment, better LF ratings, more consistent behavior.
- Student grade: budget-friendly for practice and sketchbooks.
- Value check: compare price per pencil, open-stock availability, and how many colors you’ll actually use.
Availability, Open Stock & System Support
Refilling favorites saves buying whole sets.
- Look for: open stock, spare trays, compatible accessories (water brushes, erasers).
- Watch out for: discontinued colors, hard-to-find replacements.
Safety & Sustainability
Good to know if you sell originals or teach.
- Look for: non-toxic marks (AP/CE), responsibly sourced wood (e.g., FSC), minimal odor.
- Watch out for: vague safety info, inconsistent labeling.
How to Test a Set in 5 Minutes
- Make a dry swatch + wet swatch for 6–8 colors (a primary triad, earth, dark neutral, a bright).
- Do a one-pencil gradient and pull it with water.
- Layer two glazes after the first wash dries.
- Try detail lines (dry) over a dry wash—check sharpness and lift.
- Note paper behavior (buckling, pilling) and any ghost lines.
Use these criteria, and you’ll pick pencils that suit your style, your paper, and the way you like to paint—whether that’s tight line-and-wash or loose, expressive color.
Other articles in the drawing pencils, pens, and markers series:
- Best Colored Pencils for Artists
- Best Pencil Sharpener for Colored Pencils
- Best Mechanical Pencil for Drawing
- Best Drawing and Sketching Pencils
- Best Erasers for Artists and Crafters
- Best Drawing Pens
- Best Copic Alternatives
Other articles in the Watercolor, Acrylic, Gouache, and Oils series:
- Best Watercolor Sketchbook
- Best Watercolor Paints
- Best Watercolor Paper
- Best Watercolor Brushes
- Best Watercolor Canvas for Painting: Buy It or Prepare Your Own
- Best Oil Paint Sets for Artists
- Best Palette Knives and Palette Knife Set
- Best Oil Pastels for Artists
- Best Gouache Paint Sets
- Best Artist Inks
- Best Acrylic Paint Brushes for Artists
- Best Acrylic Paint for Artists
- Best Acrylic Paper and Canvas for Artists
- Best Easels for Painting
Hi, I am Iva (rhymes with “viva”). I am a full-time self-taught artist behind Art Side of Life® and a Top Teacher on Skillshare. I have 15 years of experience in the creative field as a concept designer, illustrator, art director, and now freelance artist, content creator, and art instructor. My goal is to help you get your creative groove on with Procreate and make awesome art through practical classes, tutorials, Procreate brushes, and guides on art tools, supplies and resources. About me »
